By Mark Ferguson – Writer, CAC Market Values …..
Whereas costs for a lot of basic commemorative half {dollars} are at historic lows, some high-end commems are buying and selling at document excessive costs. An incredible instance is the sale of a 1936 York County, Maine Tercentenary half greenback that offered finally August’s Stack’s Bowers Galleries American Numismatic Affiliation conference public sale. With a mintage of 81,826, this coin concern definitely isn’t uncommon. As compared, a number of different commemorative half {dollars} issued in 1936 had mintages of 20,000 to 25,000. But, the York that offered final August introduced a document $102,000 USD.
Grade, eye attraction and the “registry amassing impact” pushed the value of this coin into new territory for a standard concern commem. Graded MS 69 by PCGS, the coin additionally obtained a CAC sticker of approval, making this coin the one silver commemorative stickered by CAC in MS 69. As anticipated, cash on the highest grade ranges possess extraordinary eye attraction, and with its wealthy multi-color firming, this “technically good” York half greenback isn’t any exception.
This six-figure worth is yet another demonstration of power in a selected phase of the early commemorative market: engaging MS 66 to MS 67 and higher-grade CAC commems. Relaxation assured, although, you don’t have to purchase “top-of-the-CAC-pop” commems to take part, that means the very best grade given to a person coin concern as discovered on the CAC Inhabitants Report. Just one collector at a time can personal the MS 69 York. Others must accept an MS 68 or MS 68+ York if they need a top-grade coin. CAC has accepted and stickered 13 York half {dollars} in MS 68 – which you must be capable to purchase for $2,500 to $3,500, if you will discover one.
Stepping down a notch, you must be capable to discover an MS 67 or MS 67+ CAC York half greenback for $300 to $500, relying on eye attraction and public sale competitors. In proudly owning a CAC MS 67 or MS 67+ York half greenback, you’ll have a pretty coin in a excessive grade for which there’s moderately sturdy demand.
Weak demand and traditionally low costs for early commemorative half {dollars} are discovered within the decrease grade cash: usually, MS 65 to MS 66 and decrease, relying on the problem. If you wish to put collectively a set of basic commemorative half {dollars} at a relatively affordable worth, you are able to do so with cash within the decrease mint state grades. Simply don’t count on these cash to understand in worth. The truth is, following the historic worth pattern of basic commems within the decrease Mint State grades demonstrates that they might soften much more in worth. The first motive is that almost all basic silver commemorative half {dollars} have been saved as worthwhile souvenirs they usually remained in Mint State. The out there provide of commems within the decrease Mint State grades outnumbers lively patrons and that’s why costs have been softening.
The very best likelihood for appreciation within the values of basic silver commems is within the higher-grade cash, these with CAC stickers of approval. As proven above within the York instance, you possibly can drop down a grade or half grade, with a plus-grade coin, and costs are sometimes considerably decrease than for the subsequent larger grade. There are additionally many various amassing themes that can help you restrict your assortment of commemorative halves to just some cash. Common themes embody Civil Conflict points, geographic themes or well-known individuals, to call just a few. After all, constructing a 50-piece design kind set is one other frequent various to amassing all 144 commems.
Final Might, Legend Rare Coin Auctions offered a 1936-D Columbia half greenback graded PCGS/CAC MS 68+ for $15,863. It’s the one instance in CAC MS 68+ that’s on document as having offered at public sale. Its worth compares to 2 PCGS/CAC MS 68 items that introduced $4,556 final Might in a GreatCollections sale and $4,320 final June in a Heritage sale.
In December, Legend offered an MS 67 PCGS/CAC 1926-S Oregon Path half greenback for $7,050. That worth compares to 2 PCGS/CAC MS 68 examples that Heritage offered final yr for $4,800 and $7,800.
A PCGS/CAC MS 67 Spanish Path half greenback was auctioned by GreatCollections for $13,250 final March. As compared, the agency offered two different PCGS/CAC Spanish Path half {dollars} final yr that have been graded the identical for $3,094 and $1,997.
All three cash have comparable appears, so why is there such a big distinction in worth? The high-priced coin was housed in a primary technology PCGS “rattler” holder and stickered by CAC. In addition to being a pretty coin, the coin’s CAC-stickered, first technology holder is a collectible, too. Folks actually do acquire coin holders. Notice that some coin holders can add a big premium to the value of a coin, and if it has a gold CAC sticker, you could be shocked as to how a lot patrons pays for it. A little analysis might repay massive.
Traditional silver commemoratives have had a nasty rap for years. As I said above, that is due to the excessive ratio of the availability of medium- to low-grade Mint State commems to collectors (patrons). That provide/demand ratio has allowed values to slowly slide for that phase of the early commem market over a interval of a few years. If you wish to acquire and spend money on early silver commemorative half {dollars} which have the perfect likelihood for appreciation, you’ll have to purchase into high-grade CAC cash.
Once more, you don’t have to purchase “top-of-the-CAC-pop” cash. A grade or a half grade decrease than a top-of-the-pop coin could serve you even higher. Prime-of-the-pop cash carry a draw back threat in that their costs might fall if a number of others get graded the identical or larger.
Figuring out how a lot to pay for these cash is one other matter. As proven above, a number of cash of the identical concern, graded the identical by the identical grading companies routinely promote for various costs. Firming and total eye attraction of the cash are the first causes for worth variations, along with the make-up of bidders competing towards one another in auctions.
My subsequent article will focus on why valuing CAC cash utilizing market worth ranges versus single worth factors gives a greater indication of worth. I’ll additionally go into the right way to use market worth ranges to assist decide the worth of a CAC coin. Within the meantime, you will get “A Information to Valuing CAC Cash” without cost at www.CACMarketValues.com.
* * *
In regards to the Creator
Mark Ferguson is an expert numismatist and writer of CAC Market Values, an impartial worth information for CAC cash. He has been an impartial coin seller since 1969, a former skilled coin grader for PCGS, and the previous market analyst for Coin World’s Coin Values journal.
